Saturday, April 24, 2010

A signalling fly Poecilobothrus nobilitatus

I am an amateur naturalist trying to learn something about everything living in my garden.

I have a plastic tub in my garden that has become partly filled with rainwater. Passing it last summer, my attention was caught by some flies busying themselves at the water's edge. A closer look revealed some fascinating behaviour: the wings of my flies were characteristically marked and the flies were solemnly raising and lowering them just as might an airport worker guiding a plane to a parking spot with a pair of semaphore flags.

I took some photo's though I confess I rather expected to fail to identify my fly. There are so many species (more than 15,000 in Europe) that to identify an unknown fly can be a tall order unless you're willing to spend hours with a magnifying glass and have access to some serious, specialist literature. Fortunately however, it turned out my fly is not uncommon, its behaviour having been noted by a fair few people, and an internet search led me to the species name: Poecilobothrus nobilitatus.

The stately wing-spreading displays of my fly are part its courtship display. As everyone knows, courtship displays are very widespread in the animal kingdom and can be fantastically intricate (one need only think of peacocks or the dance of Great Crested Grebes (video here)) . It's very natural to wonder what purpose such displays serve. Vast amounts of literature exist on this topic, with a great many unknowns and disputed theories. I don't have anything like the knowledge to comment expertly. My blog is about my learning something of my garden's natural history however, so a few facts gathered from some general reading on my part seem in order:

According to my copy of An Introduction to Behavioural Ecology (Krebs and Davies), the modern view is that, at the deepest level, courtship arises from a conflict between males and females over scarce resources. The point is that sperm are small and energetically 'cheap' to produce. Eggs, however, are larger and energetically more costly to produce and gestate. In the jargon, eggs are a scarce resource. Since eggs are, in this sense 'expensive, high value objects' it is worth males investing effort and energy competing for them. Equally, for females it pays to be 'choosy' when it comes to 'cashing in' the energy investment an egg represents.

The argument above might seem rather abstract, but its consequences are deep. Take the issue of mating with a wrong species: Some species of fruit flies for example, can and sometimes do, interbreed. Often this inter-species breeding results in sterile offspring however. From the perspective above, such parents have wasted precious time and energy. Clearly, it would have benefited them to have had some way to accurately check a prospective partner's species prior to mating. The elaborate courtship dances of some fly species (see here for example) may be just this: a way for females to check whether a male is of the correct species. From the female viewpoint, this avoids wasted energy on improper fertilization of her 'expensive' eggs. From the male point of view, although dancing costs him some energy, eggs are a scarce resource and having found some (i.e. a fertile female) it is worth the investment.

To take a second instance: Since eggs are a scarce resource it is important to lay them somewhere safe and where there is enough food available for the hatchlings. Some courtship displays - such as those where a male presents a female with some 'gift' (say, a morsel of food or a beak-full of nesting material) may be a way for the sexes to share the energetic cost of laying in a particular location (the female pays the cost of depositing her precious eggs; the male pays the cost of finding and presenting a 'courtship gift' that proves the location's suitability).

Yet another purpose of a courtship display may for females to test whether a male is a fit, strong individual, and able to pass on good genes to the egg. Actually, one needs to be a little careful before asserting a given courtship display is about a male demonstrating genetic fitness. To see why, imagine a species of bird that shows-off some glossy plumage during courtship. To say the male is demonstrating genetic fitness, makes an assumption that there exists an (inheritable) gene for glossy plumage for that bird. There may be, but on the other hand there may not. It could be that a male's glossy feathers are nothing to do with his genes but are due to him having been living somewhere that allowed him a good a plentiful food supply. The fact that females are choosing glossy feathers may be nothing (or perhaps only indirectly) to do with a male's genes, but because they say: "Food here is plentiful. It's a good place to breed". The point is not that advertising 'good genes' can never be a reason for a courtship display, simply that one cannot take it for granted as an explanation.

Anyway, in summary, a modern view is that courtship is about competition for resources between males and females. The successful male gets the benefit of the female's energy investment in eggs. In return females get an energy expenditure (=courtship display) from a male that relays something of benefit such as 'this is a good place to lay', or 'the male before you is the correct species', or 'the male before you has 'good' genes', or...(there are lots of other scenarios).

This barely makes a dent on a vast subject of course, and a great deal more could be written on the theory of courtship. This isn't the place to do it however, and instead let's get back to talking specifically about the my fly P. nobilitatus:

The best freely available online paper about my fly I came across was that of Zimmer, Diestelhorst and Lunau which describes the courtship behaviours of eight, so-called 'long legged flies' (Dolichopodidae), mine included. A number of these flies carry display 'badges' they use in courtship. Liancalus virens for example, also has signalling spots on its wings (see picture here). Neurigona quadrifasciata (here) uses foot markings to signal to females.

The paper provides a number of interesting facts about my fly. Firstly, experiments show that male wing span is directly proportional to body size: males with a big thorax also have big wing spans. During courtship P. nobilitatus males work to keep at a constant distance of 2.5cm from females. Taking these facts together, a plausible hypothesis is that female P. nobilitatus flies consider male body size important (as an indicator of a male's health status perhaps). By this argument the male's wing badges and constant- separation-dance are present in order to help females accurately estimate the body size of their suitor by sight.

Another intriguing suggestion in the paper is that males may have evolved signalling 'badges' to allow them to mate on the ground. The idea is this: some species of flies court in flight with males performing aerial stunts or hovering. Presumably these difficult and energetic winged manoeuvres may again allow females to assess health by looking at, say, wingspan. Now, suppose a male could 'con' a female's reproductive senses into thinking she was being presented with a hovering male when in fact both were sat firmly on the ground?! This is not as implausible as it sounds when we remember we are talking about a little fly whose intelligence and eyesight are not necessarily great! The female's reproductive senses may detect the 'beating' wings of a hovering male simply by whether her eyes detect (say) the outline of a wing and certain patterns of light and dark in the space before her. If a male could replicate these patterns whilst still on the ground, he might be able to fool the female's senses into a mating response, and at the same time save himself from the energetically costly business of hovering. The technical term for such cheating is 'sexual mimicry'. The paper concedes that this idea remains unproven for the long legged flies. I hope you'll agree however it's fascinating stuff and it all goes to show just how incredibly rich and intricate are the patterns of life just outside our front doors.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

Lady's Smock Cardamine pratensis

I am an amateur naturalist trying to learn something about everything living in my garden.

Photo 1 shows an attractive flower I found growing wild in a neglected corner of my garden early last summer.

A little time spent with my trusty copy of The Wildflower Key (Francis Rose) and I'm fairly confident my plant is Lady's Smock. The leaves of my plant are also rather characteristic (photo 2) with the lower leaves tending towards round with the largest leaf being the one furthest from the stem, whilst the upper leaves are rather long and narrow.

My copy of The Englishman's Flora (Geoffrey Grigson) lists around thirty alternative common names for Lady's Smock from the pretty Cuckoo Bread, Cuckoo flower, Lucy Locket and Milking Maids to the less flattering Pig's Eyes and Bog Spink!

The scientific name for my flower is Cardamine pratensis. Pratensis is from the Latin 'of meadows'. From some web searching I understand Cardamine owes its heritage to the anicent Greek physician Dioscorides (ca. 50AD) who used the name for some cress-like plants, karda being Greek for 'heart', and damao to 'tame or overpower'. (I've read that Lady's Smock is an edible, spicy, salad leaf, though I can't vouch for the truth of this.)

Lady's Smock is a favoured food of the caterpillars of the Orange Tip butterfly.

C. pratensis is a perennial, native to the British Isles and is highly variable. The paper here gives a flavour of the lengths the professionals have gone to in attempting to characterise it. My copy of New Flora of the British Isles (Stace) sums things up rather bluntly however as "impossible to subdivide usefully; identity of [named] variants [...] is very dubious". My attempt to get some basic amateur understanding of the issue led me into a study of polyploidy. I'm certainly no expert on genetics but briefly my understanding is this:

As most people know, at times the DNA inside living cells gets packaged into structural units, the chromosomes. A microscope reveals we have 46 chromosomes. Closer investigation reveals that these 46 are in fact present as two largely similar sets of 23 i.e. 23 chromosomes from our mother and a similar 23 from our father. (The phrase 'largely similar' skips over a wealth of detail, such as the fact that a certain chromosome from our mother might carry a different characteristic, say eye colour, to that from our father etc. - but never mind that here) . For humans we say "2n=46". Other mammals have other chromosome counts, for example I read variously on the web that the kangaroo has a mere 2n=12 whilst the European hedgehog boasts 2n=88 (in general there is no link between chromosome number and the size or complexity of a creature).

In the case of many plants, a lesser number of insects, amphibians, fish and a very few mammals (one being an Argentinian Plains Rat - see the parade of polyploids here!) however, things are more complicated. Some varieties of strawberry for example contain not, as we humans, two largely similar sets of 23 chromosomes but no fewer than eight sets of seven chromosomes. This gets written as "8x=56". This condition of having more than two sets of chromosomes is termed polyploidy.

The fact that more than 30% of plants go in for polyploidy would seem to indicate it must have some important benefits. There are many theories as to what these benfits might be. It's been suggested for example, that polyploidy may promote greater variation in a species and thereby help it evolve ('radiate') more easily into new environments, or that polyploidy may provide protection against 'in-breeding' issues that might otherwise arise for plants that self-fertilise. It seems also that some polyploids are healthier and more vigorous than non-polyploids. In all however, there seems to be no universally accepted theory of why so many plants are polyploids. Another of nature's mysteries!

Anyway, all of this preamble basically allows me to comment that my garden weed occurs in a bewildering variety of genetic 'forms' from the 'diploid' 2n(=2x)=16 through types with chromosomes numbers of 14, 15, 16, 19, 20, 21 – 28, 30, 32, 37, 42, 44, 45 and 48.

After the science, who better to have the last word than the Bard. From the song 'Spring' at the end of Love's Labour's Lost:
When daisies pied and violets blue,
And lady-smocks all silver white,

And cuckoo-buds of yellow hue
Do paint the meadows with delight,

Sunday, March 7, 2010

Painted Lady Butterfly Vanessa (Cynthia) cardui

I am an amateur naturalist trying to learn something about everything living in my garden.

Photo 1, taken back in late Summer, shows a Painted Lady butterfly enjoying a well-earned rest on a leaf in my garden. I say 'well earned' as this butterfly will likely have undergone an amazing 1000 mile migration, to arrive in my garden from North Africa.

The entire British population of Painted Ladies (Ladys?) arrives here in Spring and leaves again in Autumn (strictly not all leave, but those that don't fail to survive the British winter).

To have encountered a Painted Lady in my garden last Summer is perhaps unremarkable when you learn that 2009 was a mass migration year for Painted Ladies to the UK. Millions arrived, with one flutter (the collective noun for butterflies) alone of 18,000 spotted off the South Coast of England.

A fun thing to know (who knows, it may help you win a pub quiz one day!) is that the Painted Lady is the only species of butterfly recorded from Iceland. I got this fact from the admirable UK Butterflies site, which contains numerous facts and photos about the lifestyle and food preferences of the Painted Lady that I'll not reiterate here. Suffice to say that caterpillars of the Painted Lady are dark and hairy and feed on thistles and nettles.

My searches for information on my butterfly were complicated by the fact that some sources seem to use the Latin name Vanessa cardui, others Cynthia cardui, and still others talk about the species cardui in the genus Vanessa and sub-genus Cynthia. I've not had a chance to sort out which is the professionally accepted name. Anyone?

Another topic my searches led me to was the (new for me) subject of 'foraging theory'. This is a huge topic and the reader should be take my (decidedly amateur) understanding and description with a 'health warning'. Briefly however my understanding goes like this: We've all watched bees and butterflies drifting through patches of flowers, or watched little songbirds working their way through the tree tops pecking at tidbits. Perhaps, like me, you've never really noticed any particular pattern or method to the foraging of these animal. At a glance, butterflies for example, seem to drift along haphazardly, landing on any such plant as they encounter and (one might presume) staying there for as long as it takes to drink a flower's nectar dry. In fact, many years of fabulously detailed studies by armies of biologists have shown that the foraging practices of many animals are anything but random. Quite the contrary, foraging animals have evolved highly specific methods and rhythms, carefully fine tuned to allow them to optimally gather food from their environments.

A classic example of decidedly non-random foraging was revealed by the studies by Messrs. Richardson and Verbeek (you can find one of their papers here) on the feeding habits of a population of crows in British Columbia. The crows were foraging on a beach for clams. Now, you might naively assume that a crow would simply gobble up any clam it came across. This fails to take account of the fact however, that a crow has first to open up a clam's shell in order to get at the meat inside. Now, little clams don't take much time and energy to open...but then, they don't yield much meat either. Huge clams yield lots meat...but they require the crow to spend a lot of time and energy to get them open. From this you start to realise that if a crow is to get the maximum food benefit from an hour (say) spent feeding, there will be some optimal clam size the crow should target in order to spend the least time for the most meat. Amazingly, this is what the studies showed: the crows were selecting just those sizes of clam that allowed them to maximise their average energy intake.

Similar studies have been replicated across many animals with the same results: crabs show optimised strategies similar to those of crows when selecting the size of mussels to open and eat; studies on brooding starlings show that parent starlings will continue to hunt for worms in the field until they are have just the number of worms held in their beaks that optimises the bird's efficiency in getting to and from the nest (Carry too few worms and the parents must make too many energy-sapping flights back and forth to feed the chicks. On the other hand, spending too long in the field trying to peck up worms with a beak already stuffed full is slow and cumbersome and results in the parent trying to carry an excessively heavy load back to the nest); Male Yellow dung flies show behaviour that optimises the balance of time and energy spent feeding vs. the time and energy spent in moving between dung heaps looking for females with which to mate.

Actually, although foraging behaviour can be discussed using words as above, in using phrases such as ' the maximum energy acquired per unit time' etc. the numerically minded amongst you may start to realise we are approaching the possibility of a mathematical desciption of foraging ( time-rates-of-change of quantities are the 'bread and butter' of the calculus you may recall from school). A mathematical description of foraging is just what the professional biological community has developed. The classic textbook Foraging Theory by Stephens and Krebs, gives a flavour.

Some of the seminal early work on foraging was by Charnov in 1970's. Charnov developed an important theorem known as the marginal value theorem which dealt with the situation of an animal foraging between patches of food spaced some distance apart (separated patches of flowers in a meadow for example). The question is, how long should a feeder spend in any given patch before moving on? Spend too long in one patch and the available food dwindles away (the animal is reduced to hunting around for the few remaining 'scraps' so to speak). Equally it takes time and energy to fly between patches. Charnov's theory was developed to predict the optimal time an animal should remain in any one patch in order to maximise its average rate of energy intake (or to put it another way, the foraging pattern resulting in the animal getting, on average, the most calories per hour).

All of which preamble, brings me back to the Painted Lady and the papers I came across by F.R. Hainsworth. Hainsworth studied whether Painted Ladies follow the predictions of the marginal value theorem. Specifically he studied how Painted Ladies reacted to being offered sugar-water solutions of varying strengths. Should Painted Ladies be following the predictions of the marginal value theorem then they should preferentially feed on those sugar solutions that would allow them to take up, on average, the most energy per hour. Now, a crow having to wrestle with opening a clam shell or a fly having to divide its precious time between feeding and mating is one thing. But you may wonder what's to stop a butterfly simply opting to feed on the most sugary solution offered every time? The answer is satisfyingly subtle: you must remember that a butterfly is constrained to having to feed through a straw! (The proboscis). If you imagine yourself being hungry but constrained to eat through a straw, you'll realise that whilst a thick gloopy syrup will certainly provide you more total energy than a thin watery one, sucking a jar of treacle through a straw is certainly no quick meal! When you realise this, an answer to the question of what sugar concentration in water will allow you to imbibe the most calories per hour is suddenly not so obvious.

I can't help but digress at this point to briefly address the question: How do you gather data on the feeding preferences of a butterfly? One option is to chase your specimen around a forest with a stopwatch! Preferable of course, is to find some way to get a captive butterfly to eat 'on demand' in the laboratory. This might sound tricky but Hawksworth provides a wonderfully simple solution that any suitably motivated amateur could replicate (naturally, you need a supply of butterflies but there are various companies on the web that will sell you eggs and caterpillars). The trick is to know that butterflies can taste through their feet! Gently hold your butterfly between thumb and finger, lower its feet into a dish of sugar water and, bingo!, it will instinctively unroll its proboscis and begin to feed. Get yourself a stopwatch and you're all ready to test the marginal value theorem!

Anyway to return to our main question: Are the eating habits of Painted Lady's in agreement with the marginal value theorem, with butterflies eating so as to maximise their average rate of energy uptake? Interestingly, the answer seems to be no. Instead, Painted Ladies go for meals that give them the most energy in one sitting (even though it may take longer to eat such a meal). This doesn't mean the marginal value theorem is 'wrong' (as above, it applies well in some situations), it simply means that one or more of the assumptions upon which this theorem is based don't apply to the Painted Lady. One suggestion is that rather than playing the 'long game' of choosing sugar solutions that maximise the calorie intake over a long period of time, newly emerged female butterflies are keen to pack in high calorie meals early, in order that they can quickly take on board enough energy to enable them to lay a large clutch of eggs. Whether this is the full story however appears to require more study...but then of course, you, dear reader, now know how to approach the task of conducting butterfly feeding experiments. I'm entirely confident therefore, that the answers will be with us shortly!

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Helophilus pendulus hoverflies

I am an amateur naturalist trying to learn something about everything living in my garden.

Photo 1, taken back in September, shows two mating hoverflies resting on a leaf of my garden Buddleja bush. The characteristic brown stripes on the thorax quickly let me identify the species as Helophilus pendulus in my copy Hoverflies (Francis Gilbert, Richmond Publishing), an excellent monograph I've talked about before.

I assume the pair in photo 1 is male and female. Apparently it's normally possible to tell the two sexes apart in hoverflies by the eyes: The eyes of males touch at the top of the head, whereas those of females don't. Unfortunately this isn't true of Helophilus species. Why, generally, hoverfly sexes should differ in this regard, and specifically why they don't in Helophilus species, I can't imagine. Can anyone comment?

As I've mentioned previously, it's possible to distinguish hoverflies ('Syrphinae') from other flies by the veinature of the wings. In photo 2 I've zoomed in and enhanced the shot with my camera's software. Hoverfly wings have a 'false vein' (running approximately vertical in photo 2) and a section of vein at the edge of the wing that other flies lack.

In The Encyclopedia of Land Invertebrate Behaviour, the authors, R&K Preston-Mafham, describe male H. pendulus hoverflies as searching near flowers for females but often pouncing on other species of fly by mistake.

My copy of The Colour Guide to Hoverfly Larvae (G. Rotheray, Dipterists Digest 9) explains that the larvae of H. Pendulus thrive in farmyard drains and wet manure. Nice! My web searches also turned up a paper by one E. Stanley in the Veterinary Record 1845, 1(4) that describes finding an H. Pendulus maggot infesting the spinal marrow of a horse. By appearance they are a dark brown maggot with a tail as long as the body that acts as a breathing tube.

An obvious feature of hoverflies is the resemblance of many species to wasps and bees. Indeed, as explained in the extensive and very readable paper The Evolution of Imperfect Mimicry in Hoverflies by Francis Gilbert, at least a quarter of European hoverflies are mimics. Clearly, the mimicry is simply a matter of hoverflies trying to fool birds into thinking they are a wasp that will sting them....right? Well no actually, or at least it can be said the situation is far more subtle. As the paper above highlights the subject of animal mimicry is a complex one, much studied by biologists, and a topic where numerous questions and controversies persist.

Firstly, one should not assume that the 'warning colours' of hoverflies are, in all cases, a response to the threat of bird predation. There are plenty of other animals such as dragon flies, wasps and spiders will also eat hoverflies. Spiders have been shown to have an ability to recognise the threat posed by wasps in their web, and to treat them with greater caution than they do with other insects. At the same time, some experienced birds such as Flycatchers have been shown to be rather skilled at 'seeing through' the disguise of hoverflies - readily distinguishing them from wasps.

Next there is the issue of whether what we, with our human eyes, see as a resemblance to a wasp, is the same as what a predator perceives with eyes that might have very different characteristics to our own (different colour sensitivity etc.) Experiments studying the willingness of pigeons to peck at images of various hoverflies and wasps have shown that pigeons do broadly rank resemblances of hoverflies to wasps in the same way that we do. But there are exceptions with pigeons regarding Syrphus ribesii as the most wasp-like hoverfly of all, a view not shared by humans.

Next, there is the question of whether it is a bee's or wasp's sting that a predator is avoiding and that a hoverfly is "pretending" to posses. In fact, it seems that birds hardly ever suffer wasp stings and actually it is the unpleasant taste of a wasp's internal venom sack that some birds avoid. With Bumblebees (which some hoverflies mimic) the situation is more subtle still. There is some evidence that the sheer effort (in terms of wasted time and energy) involved in removing all the various hairs and largely inedible, chitinous, 'body armour' of a bumblebee is enough to put off some birds. Contrary to proclaiming its sting, the colouration of bumblebees (and their hoverfly mimics) may be a way of saying "I'm not worth the time and calories you'll get from eating me!".

This brings us to the difference between so-called Batesian mimicry and Mullerian mimicry. Batesian mimincry is the type of mimicry most of us imagine at first, whereby a harmless insect species evolves to copy the warning colours of a harmful one. By contrast, Mullerian mimicry involves two or more species that each have defences of their own, but nevertheless carry a common warning colour or form. Lots of bees and wasps all have yellow stripes for example. One can understand how this might arise: Suppose a predator has a bad experience with a harmful species. If that predator comes to associate the bad experience with a warning marking for that one species (yellow stripes say), then there's clearly potential benefit in other poisonous species adopting similar markings. By adopting similar markings however, one wasp species is not really 'copying' another, rather, both species are gaining benefit by evolving in parallel to advertise their venomous natures through similar body markings (multiple species settling on a 'common format' for advertising their individual danger signals if you will) . Now, in saying that hoverflies 'copy' wasps we are making the tacit assumption that hoverflies are harmless Batesian mimics. This is probably mostly the case. But it need not be universal. For example, it has been suggested that some species of hoverfly concentrate unpleasant tasting chemicals in their bodies through eating aphids that have been feeding on noxious plants. Such hoverflies would have their own defences (their noxious taste) and any evolved resemblance to say wasps, might then be an example of Mullerian mimicry.

The list of fascinating questions surrounding mimicry goes on. There is the question of the drawbacks of mimicry. Naively, it might seem there could little detriment for a species in 'wearing the clothes' of another. But suppose the venomous species being copied becomes rare. If a non-venomous hoverfly were to become more common than a venomous bee (say) it might be copying, what then? Predators would rarely (or even never) meet with the bad experience of finding that the prey in their mouth was the truly venomous one. After a time predators might simply stop associating the mimic's bright colours with danger. Indeed, the bright colours of the hoverfly mimic might become a positive liability, gaudily advertising the presence of a tasty snack! In summary, by choosing to copy the colours of another species, a mimic pays the price of shackling its population size that of the target insect being copied. Exactly the nature of the constraint (i.e. the mathematical relationship between the sustainable population of the mimic vs. the copied species) is a rich topic in its own right.

I could go on still further into a discussion of polymorphism in mimics, whereby a single species of say, hoverfly, comes in a number of different (colour) forms called morphs, and the benefits this confers. I've written enough for now however and so will leave this topic for another day, or, if you cannot wait for then, refer you to the paper above by Gilbert.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

A lichen Aspicilia contorta

I am an amatuer naturalist trying to learn something about everything living in my garden.

Returning to the iron manhole cover I discussed in my last posting, photo 1 shows yet another lichen eking out a living on the metal surface. From my copy of Lichens (F. Dobson, Richmond Publishing) I'm fairly confident the lichen here is Aspicilia contorta.

The little 'volcanoes' I've marked in the picture are the lichen's spore producing fruits (apothecia). If you're trying to identify a species of a lichen it's worth knowing that apothecia come in different 'flavours', in particular lecideine and lecanorine apothecia. This is well covered in the text books, but I wasn't able to readily locate a picture on the web so I've drawn one myself (I'm no botanical illustrator as you can see!). The difference is in the margin of the fruit body: The margins of lecanorine lichen apothecia tend to be the same colour as the main underlying lichen body (thallus) and contain algae. By contrst, the margins of fruits of lecideine lichens tend to appear distinct from the thallus and do not contain algae. The latter are often black (the books sometimes refer to the margin being 'carbonised'. I don't know whether this is just poor terminology or whether the lichen really does manufacture something akin to raw carbon in the margin. Anyone?).

From the description above it will be clear Aspicilia contorta is a lecanorine lichen.

Actually, my efforts to track down a description of all this on web led me to encounter a fair amount of technical jargon surrounding apothecia that had me quite confused at first. To save any fellow interested amateurs out there the trouble of going through the same, drawing two and the description below summarises the understanding I managed to pick up.

As I'd understood from my previous experiments slicing up apothecia, lichen fuits comprise an array of asci (= little tubes filled with spores). Photo 2 shows a single ascus I managed to separate from an apothecium I took from my garden A. contorta. As shown in drawing 2, the asci come sandwiched amidts a mass of upright fungal threads ('hyphae') known as paraphyses. The specialist textbooks often include pictures of these paraphyses, as they too can help in identifying the species of a lichen.

The fact that the asci are neatly arranged in an upright position is of course, no accident. It's important to the reproductive success of the lichen that when spores exit an ascus, they do so into the open air. There would clearly be no point in having the asci oriented haphardly and liberting a substantial proportion of their spores into back into the walls of the apothecium from where they've arisen in the first place. Of course, this only explains why the asci stand upright, it doesn't explain how they know which way is 'up'. I was fascinated to learn recently however (from a copy of the classic Spore Discharge in Landplants (Ingold) that I was lucky enough to find in a secondhand bookshop) that many cup fungi are phototropic (= sensitive to the direction of daylight), and use this to beneficially orient themselves. The book describes this for various cup-fungi, and I assume it is also the mechanism used by lichens, though strictly, I haven't come across a reference to confirm this (anyone?).

The asci + paraphyses are arranged on a thin layer known as the hypothecium. This comprises a mass of dikaryotic fungal cells, each containing two DNA nuclei. By a complex process of chromosome divison (mitosis) these cells eventually form (single nucleus-) spores. The whole business of sexual reproduction in lichens is complex and there is probably a lot left to discover. The pdf document here has some details.

The outer part of the fruit (technically termed the excipulum) comprises a mass of single-DNA-nucleus (haploid) fungal cells.

So now you know!

Today's has been a rather technical posting and perhaps marks a suitable point to leave my garden's lichens for a while (though I have yet to exhaust them). Outside the first signs of Spring are here: The volume of birdsong is increasing as the breeding season approaches and today on a country walk I spotted my first ladybird of the year (despite Oxfordshire still suffering regular frosts at night), all of which suggests I will not have to look too hard for new signs of life in my garden. Until next time...

Saturday, January 30, 2010

A lichen Lecanora dispersa

I am an amateur naturalist trying to discover everything living in my garden.

I have a manhole cover in my garden. (Try to contain your excitement at hearing this news dear reader!) This may seem an unpromising place to search for life, but a closer look reveals a host of those most enterprising (in terms of the habitats they are willing to conquer) of creatures - the lichens.

Zooming in, photo 1 (click on photos to enlarge) reveals at least two species: The yellow lichen (which looks like our old friend Caloplaca citrina - though I've not taken time to carefully check this) and a second species with numerous white, frosted fruits ('apothecia').

A little time spent with my trusty copy of Lichens (Frank Dobson, Richmond Publishing) and browsing some similar images on the internet, and I'm tolerably confident the latter is the lichen Lecanora dispersa.

There are at least 20 British species of Lecanora lichen. Dobson describes L.dispersa as 'very common and found even in the centres of cities'. It will grow on a variety of basic substrates including bark, stone, iron and leather.

Photo 3 shows a magnified view of the apothecia, with their white, wrinkled rims.

For photo 4 I took one apothecium and made a squash between a microscope slide and a coverslip. As I've discussed previously, lichens are a partnership between fungi and algae. The small green, algal cells are clearly seen in photo 4. That algae can be present throughout a lichen's cup-shaped apothecia was a new discovery for me - I'd hitherto only associated them with the non-fruit parts of a lichen.

The main purpose of a lichen's apothecia is to act as surfaces from which to liberate numerous reproductive spores. I've talked about this before, but I was not previously in a position to complement my descriptions with photographs. Recently however, I've been lucky enough to come into possession of a Cambridge rocking microtome. For those unfamiliar, this is a device for taking extremely thin (~few microns) slices of a specimen, which can then be viewed under a microscope. Actually things are not entirely straightforward, since, in order to avoid said slice ripping and disintegrating as it's cut, it's necessary to first provide support to the cellular structure of the sample by embedding the whole thing in a block of wax. The recipe for doing this is a little involved: Starting from pure water, you pass the sample through half-a- dozen water+alcohol baths. The baths are arranged so that the alcohol concentration steadily increases until finally your sample is left sitting in pure alcohol, the water in the sample's cells having, by then, been replaced with alcohol. Next, you substitute the alcohol for the solvent toluene (a solvent of wax) before dropping it into a bath of molten paraffin wax and leaving for several hours. Finally, you pour the wax+sample into a mould and leave to cool. (In fact, there are still futher steps that finesse this process - but you get the general idea! Should you wish to try it yourself the best guide I've found is the booklet Practical Microscopy (Eric Marson, Northern Biological Supplies) and/or you could join one of the hobbyist microscopical societies such as the redoubtable Postal Microscopical Society.)

Photos 5 and 6 show my rocking microtome. The blue handled blade is the extremely sharp sectioning razor. The white object is the wax-block-embedded sample. Pulling the lever at the rear of the microtome (photo 5) raises the sample and releasing (photo 6) forces it down onto the blade shaving off a wafer thin slice and simultaneously ratcheting the sample forward ready to take the next.

And the consequence of all this labor?... Photo 7 shows a cross section through a lichen apothecium. Strictly, for this posting it ought to be that of L.dispersa, but working on the principle 'walk before you can run!' I instead sectioned a sample of our old friend X.parietina from my apple tree, since the latter has large apoethecia and a robust surrounding thallus (= 'body'). I've labelled up photo 7 (click to enlarge) and you can clearly see that the apothecium surface (technically termed the hymenium) comprises an assemblage of sausage-shaped 'asci' packed full of spores.

One thing puzzles me: I have not seen the granular bodies I see here labelled up in the handful of books I have on lichen. Possibly these are air bubbles. They turned up very frequently in my samples however and I don't believe they are. Can anyone comment?

Saturday, January 23, 2010

Jurassic sea creatures

I am an amateur naturalist trying to identify everything living in my garden.

Hello, and welcome to my 100th creature posting!

I started my blog three years ago almost to the day. My motivation then as now, was simple curiosity. When I began I was almost completely ignorant of the identity of many of the insects, plants, mosses and lichens in my garden.I wanted to learn a little more. I am still learning! It has been a revelation to come to realise just how rich a diversity of life there is on my doorstep, and to discover the incredible variety and subtlety of form, function and behaviour that exists just outside my window. I have encountered flies with larvae that invade the nests of bees, cup-shaped fungi that close the 'roof' in the dry weather, hoverflies that can regulate their body temperature and spiderlings whose first meal is their own mother. It has been a further revelation for me to learn what an enormously detailed body of knowledge exists regarding the natural world (sixty years' worth of data on a Scarlet Tiger moth population in a woodland in Oxfordshire; a study of the behaviour of the Greyling butterflies taking in a staggering 50,000 experimental tests; an online database of 125,000 species of algae...) and yet at the same time, what a mass of unanswered questions exist that that any sufficiently motivated amateur could answer, thereby make a lasting contribution to human knowledge. I find it an inspiration to keep looking and learning about the countryside when I read that of 265 British species of hoverfly, a staggering 40% of larvae are simply unknown (that at least was the status in 1993 according to the Colour Guide to Hoverfly Lavae, G.E.Rotheray) ; or that there are 235 sub-species of British dandelion whose distribution and ecology in the UK in only sketchily understood; or that with changing climate patterns, the amateur has every chance of spotting some immigrant creature (a ladybird, say) new to their environment.

On to today's posting. This being my centennial posting it seemed appropriate to pick something a little different, and what better than to discuss the rarest of all the creatures in my garden, so rare in fact that they have been extinct hereabouts for around 150 million years, when my garden was last a submerged mass of Jurassic oyster beds and coral reefs.

What I know about the geology of my garden I have got from reading the splendid The Geology of Oxfordshire (Philip Powell, 2005, The Dovecote Press):

For those unfamiliar with the UK, Oxfordshire is a county located towards the centre of England. Layers of strata have built up over the eons and at some point the stack of layers has been tilted, so that as you travel across the county from North to South the layer exposed at the surface beneath your feet changes from a youngest (~100 MY-old) chalk layer in the South to an oldest (~200MY-old) ironstone and clay 'lias' layer in the North. Some of these layers are softer than others and have eroded more over time, given Oxfordshire its gently undulating landscape of hills and valleys. (These are the surface-exposed rocks, were you to drill down you would hit much older rocks; 490MY-old rocks from the 'Ordovician' period are known in the neighbouring county of Buckinghamshire). The splendid people at the British Geological Survey have recently put their maps online for free viewing so you can see some of this for yourself.

The rocks in photo 1 are known as 'Wheatley Coral Rag' limestone, Wheatley being a town in Oxfordshire where they're common, although outcrops of the rocks are also found at other locations in the county including Headington (where it was extensively quarried from the 14th to the 19th century), Cowley (where, apropos of nothing, the BMW 'Mini' car is manufactured) and the hill-top village of Beckley. Probably the most magnificent example of the use of Wheatley limestone in Oxfordshire is my garden wall...although I suppose the Radcliffe Camera building (built in the 1740's) in central Oxford isn't bad either! (Photo 2 - was taken by Tom MurphyVII and I understand I can use it here under the terms of the GNU free licence). The lower 3rd of the building is the Wheatley limestone.

The material that went into making Wheatly rag was laid down in shallow seas in the Upper Jurassic period (145-161 MY-ago) when my garden would have been at a latitude of 35-40 deg. North (the latitude of Southern Spain today). The rocks are composed of masses of shards of mollusc shells, bits of sea urchin and fragments of coral. In photo 2 I've zoomed in on the rock at the rear of photo 1. I'm not a skilled photographer but I hope you get an impression of this.

I have not attempted to identify the species of my fossils. Indeed I would hardly know where to start. If one finds a fossilised Jurassic mollusc shell, is it a relatively simple matter of keying out the find from amongst a handful of known and easily distinguished species, or is exhaustive analysis needed to separate it from hundreds or even thousands of candidate Jurassic molluscs? (Can anyone comment?). Part of me would love to throw myself into a study of this, but logic tells me that with limited time to devote to my hobby, and around 750 UK species of moss, 800 larger moths, 3500 larger fungi, a similar number of lichens, 4000 species of beetle, 7000 flies, heaven only knows how many mites and nematodes...I have more than enough living species to occupy my time without embarking on a study of the extinct ones.

I am left with one lead as to species. In discussing locally discovered Corallian fossials, the book above shows images of fossil oysters of the species Nanogyra nana, corals of the species Isastrea explanata and Thecosmilia annularis and sea urchins of the species Nucleolites scutatus. Whether any of these were truely present in my garden I do not know, and even if they were they're not living there now and so strictly I shouldn't count them in my species tally. Since this is 'my party' however, I am going to flagrantly break the rules, assume at least one of them did once live in my garden, and chalk up one more species to my blog count. Complaints should be addressed to my lawyer!